In
January 2014 Fairtrade Labelling Organizations, also known as
Fairtrade International, put a cat among the pigeons, announcing the
development of the Fairtrade Sourcing Programs. Let us come back to this piece
of news, explain it and balance the pros and cons.
Fairtrade International and the system of Fairtrade label.
|
Quinoa farmers from the cooperative
working with FAIR. |
Fairtrade International was created in 1997 to be responsible for the development and the
cooperation among the different actors of the Fairtrade movement. It has
developed fair norms and standards with the will of modifying the international
trade to make it fairer for little producers of developing countries.
Before
January 2014 the system was quite simple. If a product was labeled “Fair-Trade”,
it meant that every single ingredient or component it included came from Fairtrade.
Easy to understand, but quite hard to deal with when you are an entrepreneur. Consequently
the current figures of Fairtrade are sad: the Fairtrade production of cocoa represents
only 1,2% of the market of cocoa, and most of the Fairtrade production is sold
as “not fair-trade” because the offer is far bigger than the demand.
To
solve the issue Fairtrade International announced in January a second system, complementary to
the first one, which is called the Fairtrade Sourcing Programs (FSPs).
The Fairtrade Sourcing Programs.
The goal
of FSPs is to increase Fairtrade sales at a global scale in order to get a
bigger Fairtrade Premium. The Fairtrade premium is the sum of money that companies
pay in addition of the price of the products they buy, sum that goes to the
association of producers to allow them to invest in education, healthcare, or
farm improvements. More sells mean bigger Fairtrade Premium, and so, bigger
development for emerging countries and little producers.
FSPs
consist in three programs, one for cotton, one for cocoa, and the last one for
sugar. Norms and standards do not change. The striking aspect of the project is
that a product does not need to be fully “fair-trade” but only one of its
components. For example a chocolate bar, made of 100% fair-trade chocolate, but
“normal” sugar can be considered as a Fairtrade product. It will not have the
same label as the 100% Fairtrade product, but one that shows that it takes part
of Fairtrade Sourcing Programs.
Consequences of the FSPs on the Fairtrade movement
This
is a revolution for the Fairtrade movement especially in cocoa sphere.
Therefore Ferrero committed to buy 20,000 tonnes of cocoa beans under
Fair-trade conditions. This was great news for the Fairtrade movement and
little producers of Ivory Coast, who will benefit from a long-term increase of
their incomes. Nine companies also committed themselves in the Fairtrade
Sourcing Program for cocoa: Mars, Rewe, Riegelein, Coop, Kambly, AEON, Lidl
& Kaufland, Switch.
Some
people applause, but others question the initiative. It was
the case of the United States, Canada, and Great Britain, but also many brands
attached to another vision of Fairtrade: Alteréco,
Ethiquable, Malongo, Artisans du Monde… They argue that
the goal of Fairtrade is, according to them, primarily to modify unfair rules
of international trade, and that they were afraid FSPs benefited big companies,
already really present in the markets. FSPs might then only perpetuate unfair
rules of traditional international trade.
And what’s new for products other than cocoa, sugar
and cotton?
The
CLAC, a Fair Trade producer network representing Latin American Producers, declared
to be opposed to the FSPs whereas it greeted another announcement with
enthusiasm: in July 2013 Nespresso launched a long-reaching partnership for
coffee with the AAA farmers cooperatives of the region of Caldas, Columbia.
According
to Harriet Lamb, Chief Executive of Fairtrade International said: “This
encourages the kind of development that not only helps whole communities, it
furthers emphasizes the fundamental necessity of ensuring that quality of life
of farmers is on a par with the quality of coffee they are producing.”
|
Bruce McNamer, President & CEO of Technoserve - Jean-Marc Duvoisin, CEO of Nestlé Nespresso - Tensie Whelan, President of the Rainforest Alliance - Harriet Lamb, President of Fair Trade International - Georges Clooney |
Both
FSPs and Nespresso partnership take part in a new vision of Fairtrade, more
reachable for entrepreneurs, but for clients too.